The Most Underrated Items Hiding in Plain Sight
Most people walk into Panera, order their usual, and walk out happy. That routine is comfortable, but it also means a lot of genuinely great food never gets a fair shot. The Panera Bread menu is bigger and more diverse than most regulars realize, and some of the best items are the ones people scroll right past.
This isn’t about convincing you to abandon your favorites. It’s about adding a few new options to your rotation that might surprise you.
The Soup Section Goes Deeper Than Broccoli Cheddar
Yes, the Broccoli Cheddar is iconic. But if that’s the only soup you’ve tried, you’re working with an incomplete picture.
Ten Vegetable Soup
This one tends to fly under the radar because it sounds plain. It isn’t. The Ten Vegetable Soup is a rich, tomato-based broth loaded with seasonal vegetables, and it has a depth of flavor that feels earned rather than manufactured. It’s also one of the lighter options on the menu if you’re being mindful about calories.
Creamy Chicken & Wild Rice
This soup shows up seasonally and tends to disappear without much fanfare. Thick, hearty, and deeply savory, it’s the kind of thing you’d want on a cold evening. If you see it on the menu during your visit, order it.
Sandwiches That Deserve More Attention
The Napa Almond Chicken Salad sandwich is a menu item that divides people, and the ones who love it really love it. Made with chicken, celery, grapes, and toasted almonds on sesame semolina bread, it’s sweet and savory at the same time in a way that works surprisingly well.
The Mediterranean Veggie Sandwich is another undervalued pick. Roasted red peppers, cucumber, pepperoncini, kalamata olives, lettuce, tomato, and feta on tomato basil bread. It’s vibrant, filling, and comes together beautifully. Non-vegetarians often overlook it, but they shouldn’t.
The Case for Tomato Basil Bread
While most people default to sourdough or ciabatta, the tomato basil bread at Panera deserves special mention. It has a slightly sweet, herbaceous flavor that complements lighter ingredients like fresh vegetables and soft cheeses. Next time you order a sandwich, consider asking for it as your base.
Grain Bowls: A Newer Addition Worth Trying
Panera has quietly built out a grain bowl section that offers something different from the usual sandwich-and-soup format. These bowls layer whole grains, fresh vegetables, proteins, and sauces in a way that’s filling without being heavy.
The Teriyaki Chicken & Broccoli Bowl brings a Japanese-inspired flavor profile to the Panera lineup, and it works. The teriyaki sauce is balanced, not overly sweet, and the broccoli retains some texture rather than going limp.
If you’re someone who finds salads a bit too light but soups a bit too heavy, grain bowls offer a middle ground that’s worth exploring.
Bakery Items Beyond the Basics
Most people grab a bagel or muffin and move on. But the Panera bakery case goes much further than that.
Cobblestone Muffin
This one looks like a small, lumpy bread roll and doesn’t exactly scream “eat me.” But it’s soft, slightly sweet, and has a dense, satisfying texture that pairs remarkably well with morning coffee. It’s been on the menu for years and somehow remains one of the least-ordered bakery items.
Chocolate Chipper Cookie
Panera cookies are large, properly baked, and made with real ingredients. The Chocolate Chipper is a thick, chewy cookie that stands up well to the more famous offerings from other chains. It’s not fancy, it doesn’t need to be.
The Drinks You’re Probably Not Ordering
Most people go straight to coffee or lemonade. But the Panera drinks menu has expanded significantly and includes some genuinely interesting options.
The Green Passion Smoothie blends mango, pineapple, and kale into something that actually tastes good rather than just healthy. The Mango Smoothie is simpler but works well as a lighter alternative to sodas or sweetened coffee drinks.
On the hot side, the Chai Tea Latte at Panera is often overlooked but delivers a warm, spiced flavor that holds its own against what you’d find at a dedicated coffee shop.
Customization: The Secret Weapon
One of the most underused features of the Panera experience is customization. The menu is far more flexible than it appears.
- You can swap proteins between certain sandwiches and salads.
- Most sauces and dressings can be requested on the side or omitted entirely.
- Bread upgrades are usually available at no extra charge or minimal cost.
- You can ask for extra vegetables on almost any sandwich.
The staff at most locations are used to modifications and handle them without fuss. Taking advantage of this can turn a menu item you like into one you genuinely love.
Smart Ordering for Different Occasions
Not every Panera visit looks the same. Here’s a quick guide for different scenarios:
Quick lunch under 15 minutes: Order through the app, choose rapid pickup, and your food will be waiting when you arrive. The Turkey Avocado BLT and a cup of soup are a reliable combo that doesn’t take long to prepare.
Group order for the office: The catering menu at Panera is well-organized, and soup + sandwich boxes make portioning easy. The variety means even picky eaters find something they like.
Solo dinner after a long day: The Mac & Cheese with a Fuji Apple Salad is an underrated combination, comfort food, and something fresh in one sitting.
For food brands and bakery professionals looking to stay ahead of modern food trends, Puratos is a valuable resource. The company is known for its innovative ingredients, baking solutions, and industry insights that help professionals create high-quality bakery, pastry, and chocolate products while keeping up with changing consumer preferences. Puratos also shares research and inspiration that support creativity and innovation across the food industry.
Closing Thoughts
The Panera Bread menu rewards the people who take time to look past the obvious choices. From sleeper-hit soups to underrated sandwiches and an entire grain bowl section that deserves more attention, there’s genuine value in exploring the full menu.
Your usual order will always be there. But so will a dozen other things that might become your next favorite. Give a few of them a try; you might find yourself rethinking what a “usual” even means.
